Update, Nov. 16 at 10:27 a.m. Central: The Commerce Department’s Bureau of Industry and Security released an interim final rule addressing remote access to advanced chips and servers. The agency said the rule targets access to restricted computing power through data centers in third countries. The Associated Press reported on the rule Monday. It addresses one of the issues raised in Cantwell’s letter.
Sen. Maria Cantwell is calling on Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick to tighten controls on advanced artificial intelligence chips, arguing that companies with ties to China can still obtain access to U.S. computing power through overseas firms. The Washington Democrat’s letter, dated Sunday and released Monday, comes as Lutnick prepares to travel with President Donald Trump to China for the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit.
Cantwell, the ranking Democrat on the Senate Commerce Committee, asked the department to account for its enforcement decisions and take steps to block transfers she says compromise U.S. technological leadership. The letter lays out her case for administrative action under existing law.
Where Cantwell wants tighter enforcement
The letter raises two related questions about how restrictions apply when an intermediary is involved. One is whether companies in China can obtain access to advanced computing power from overseas providers that use American chips. The other is how export restrictions apply to subsidiaries that are majority owned by companies already subject to U.S. restrictions.
Cantwell pointed to Commerce’s suspension of a Bureau of Industry and Security rule that would extend certain restrictions to those subsidiaries. Her concern is that a company already subject to controls could turn to an affiliated business to acquire technology it would face restrictions on obtaining directly. The letter also questioned the department’s handling of an inquiry into possible chip diversion. That account is an allegation in the letter.
What happens next
Cantwell cited the Export Control Reform Act of 2018 as the basis for Commerce to act. The department administers federal export controls through its Bureau of Industry and Security. Any new restrictions or changes to existing rules would depend on what the department does after the letter.
The Associated Press reported on the letter as part of its coverage of Trump’s Asia trip. Trump is traveling first to Manila and then to Shenzhen, where he is expected to meet Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin. The trip gives the administration several diplomatic issues to handle at once, including trade and nuclear talks. Cantwell’s request concerns Commerce’s enforcement decisions, which can proceed on a separate track from the summit.
For chipmakers and cloud computing providers, the practical question is whether Commerce changes which customers, subsidiaries or overseas transactions are subject to restrictions. The letter itself leaves those rules in place.