The U.S. Department of Energy has issued another emergency order requiring a western Michigan coal plant to stay available this winter, months after a federal appeals court rejected the department’s earlier use of emergency authority for the facility.
The Nov. 13 order directs the Midcontinent Independent System Operator, working with Consumers Energy, to keep the J.H. Campbell Generating Facility in West Olive available from Nov. 15 through Feb. 12, 2027. The department cited risks to the regional power supply.
Keeping the plant available does not require it to run around the clock. The order directs the grid operator to use economic dispatch, meaning it should account for operating costs when deciding which units to call on. The order directs MISO to dispatch Campbell only during hours when it is needed to address the emergency and to minimize costs to ratepayers. MISO coordinates electricity across a region that extends beyond Michigan, so the department’s stated reliability concern is regional.
Why the order is disputed
Federal officials invoked Section 202(c) of the Federal Power Act, which gives the energy secretary authority to respond to electricity emergencies. The department argues that regional planning and state action cannot address the reliability risk quickly enough. Earlier orders had already kept the facility available beyond its planned retirement.
The D.C. Circuit ruled in September that earlier orders in the Campbell dispute exceeded the department’s authority. The new directive is the seventh order for the plant since May 2025, the Associated Press reported. Environmental groups told the AP there was no evidence that keeping Campbell available had prevented outages.
For customers, the order itself establishes an operating requirement rather than a new electric rate. It does not specify a household bill increase or say how often the plant will be called on this winter. Those are separate questions from the federal decision to keep the units available.
The latest order has a defined end date, and it allows time for an orderly shutdown after it concludes. Until then, the practical question is how often the grid operator calls on the plant. The legal question is whether the department’s latest justification can support another emergency extension after the appeals court’s ruling on the earlier orders.