The Supreme Court declined Monday to hear Novotny v. Moore, a challenge to a Maryland law that restricts carrying firearms in designated public places. The denial leaves the federal appeals court’s ruling in place and ends this petition without a Supreme Court ruling on the merits.
What the denial leaves in place
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit upheld most of Maryland’s challenged restrictions, according to Justice Clarence Thomas’s statement accompanying Monday’s order. The Associated Press reported that the case concerns limits on where people may carry guns, including places the state treats as sensitive.
The constitutional dispute concerns how courts apply the Supreme Court’s 2022 Bruen decision. That decision recognized a right to carry a firearm in public for self-defense and directed courts to assess restrictions against the country’s historical tradition of firearm regulation. It also recognized that certain sensitive places can be subject to restrictions. The dispute in Maryland centered on how far that category may extend.
Thomas signals the issue could return
Thomas wrote separately to express doubts about broad restrictions that cover many places where people gather. He said the court should consider the constitutionality of particular restrictions in an appropriate future case. His statement reflects his own view and does not alter the outcome of Monday’s order.
For Maryland, the immediate effect is procedural. The appeals court ruling remains in place, and the Supreme Court has set no briefing or argument in this case. Challenges to other states’ laws can reach the court separately, depending on how those cases proceed.